AnnoBib -- “Cognition, Convention, and Certainty: What We Need to Know about Writing”

-
Bizzell, Patricia. “Cognition, Convention, and Certainty: What We Need to Know about Writing.” PRE/TEXT 3.3 (1982): 212-243. Rpt. in Cross-Talk in Comp Theory: A Reader Ed. Victor Villanueva, Jr. Urbana, IL: National Council of Teachers of English, 1997. 365-389. Print.
Claims that the “writing problem” is actually a “thinking problem,” that R/C instruction had previously presumed only to help thinkers put their ideas on paper with style and mechanics. Distinguishes between inner-directed (language-learning and thinking processes prior to social influence) and outer-directed (social, communal) cognitive processes. Bizzell's description of discourse communities seems Vygotskian, though she does not mention his work here (369). Outer-directed theorists believe that students can't think or use language we want them to because of lack of exposure, and that instructors should be looking for ways to explain or analyze discourse communities (areas of experience), including explaining the conventions and expectations of the academic discourse community. Outer-directed theory can shore up the Flower-Hayes model (lacking the ability to advise students in practice) by providing planning and translating strategies. Here, Bizzell introduces Vygotsky's characterization of “verbal thought” and suggests that his analysis would not separate planning and translation, but conditioned by social context.
    Bizzell strongly criticizes the Flower-Hayes model because it neglects the role of knowledge during composition, and fails to see convention's generative power in poor writers. Bizzell feels that poor writers are simply unfamiliar with the academic discourse community with limited experience and lack awareness of community conventions. Criticizes the inner-directed theorists as a simplistic and emotionally reactive approach that is “likely to satisfy complaining faculty and administrators, and because its claim to a basis in universals assures us … we aren't touching the student's own culture but merely giving them away around it” (384).
    Though Bizzell claims that the purpose of her critique of Flower and Hayes' work is "not to delegitimate" it, and though she says we should value the both the outer-directed and inner-directed theories, it certainly seems like she's siding pretty heavily with the outer-directed camp. She certainly doesn't spend much time talking about what's right about them.

Popular posts from this blog

Student Feedback on the State of the Public Sphere in Harris County, Texas and Houston

-
Image
I asked my students (my teachers) today what they've learned so far in this summer course on public sphere rhetoric. Some held their heads down -- because they've learned nothing? -- because they've not yet learned to speak up? -- because they don't believe in public rhetoric? -- because of their own insecurities? I don't know. Most of the responses below came from five students. Their authorities take no responsibility for communicating with the stakeholders  Authoritative texts too difficult to locate; language often inappropriately difficult for public to use  Lack of sufficient documentation and literature reflects authorities' apathy towards public engagement   Our own lack of knowledge about the power structures increases both our and their apathy  Public fails to recognize problems because we have been habituated to "learned helplessness"  Public notices but feel powerless because we've been taught we can't change anything  A
Read more

On Independence Day, Fourth of July, Fireworks Day, Whatever We Call It

-
Image
In general, I avoid observing holidays, especially those which have been marketed from an original intent of respect or adoration into a Bacchanalia of barbecue, escape from one's workplace, and the purchase of stuff we don't need, stuff that will quickly be found at the local landfill. Most of these "holidays" are far from the idea of "holy days" once on the calendar, and have been mutated into something of a masquerade. When children have little idea of the original intention of a holiday, or when adults have no idea of the same, then we might have a problem. I've spoken with adults who have no idea what Memorial Day is about, never have heard of Armistice Day, never think of veterans on Veterans Day, go into significant debt for the Feast of Saturnalia (or Festivus , if you prefer), who conflate chocolate bunnies for Easter (even for Passover), and ultimately see the Fourth of July as an opportunity to leave work, eat, complain that the Postal Servic
Read more

Visiting a Texas Prison

-
It's exhausting, emotionally. It's not necessarily the emotions of why he is in prison and what he experiences in prison -- that's another discussion and I separate those emotions from the visit itself. The gates open for visitors at 7:00 a.m., but that means I need to get there at 6:30 to get in line; I arrived in Beeville the previous evening and just captured a hotel. The town has limited food selections (and poor beer selection), so I have no reason to get outdoors except to appreciate a nice spring day of south Texas. That morning, the moon was near full and brilliantly shined on the flat fields around the prison, a mix of brush oaks, and the grasses for hundreds of acres on the unit property. The chilled air made the morning even more pleasant and while I waited for the gate to open, I thought about camping down here. Ultimately, the gate guards permitted visitors to approach the gate, the first of the all-grey officers: turn off the engine, open the trunk and ho
Read more