Pygmalion or Golem? -- Writing Students and Self-Efficacy
The Parable of the Mote and Beam, Domenico Fetti, ~1619, (c) Metropolitan Museum of Art Sinned Against and Sinning I feel that somewhere, sometime, we've all sinned. We've all sinned in criticizing, mocking, deriding students' work. It's a mote-beam, problem, really, as we forget where we come from, where our writing was when we were first year students. Many of us in the teaching professions also come from different economic and literacy backgrounds that can't compare to those of our students today. This is certainly true for many students who attend community colleges such as mine, many coming from lower SES environments, struggling schools, homes with few literacy experiences other than those of mass media and family lore. I don't devalue these last two discourse environments, but too seldom are these discourses are undervalued in the first year course, many instructors adamant that the course is designed to inculcate those middle class values (Bloom) o...